$1000 Gold and $140 Oil

Home > Articles >Gold vs. Oil

 

Compare the price of Gold and Oil to see which is overpriced
 
 
 

At $1000 is Gold Expensive?

With Gold nearing $1000 and at all time nominal high prices many are wondering if Gold is overpriced.

If we look at the inflation adjusted price of Gold we see that even at $1000 it is still only about half-way to its all time highs.

For more information see Inflation Adjusted Gold Price .

But that is just one way to look at the price by comparing it to U.S. dollars. We could also look at its price in Euros or at what the price looks like to the people in China or India. And each of those are based on the values of their currency and how much they are inflating.

But a different way to look at it would be in comparison to the price of other commodities.  Theoretically in an ideal world, if the supply of currency is inflating, then all commodities should increase equally. 

But in the real world that isn't true.  There are inequalities partially because money doesn't flow equally initially.  Eventually it  will even out as traders arbitrage high priced commodities against lower priced ones. 

But how do you know which commodities are over priced and which are under priced?

 Very simply you just divide one price by the other to get a ratio.  If we look at the ratio of Gold to Oil we will see how they relate.

Since an ounce of gold is about $1000 and a barrel of oil is around $100 I decided to look at how many barrels of oil an ounce of gold would buy.  You can just as easily divide it the other way but the numbers come out messier. 

So we are looking at barrels per ounce so if Gold is at $1000 /oz and Oil is at $100/ barrel it is obvious that one ounce of gold would buy 10 barrels of oil, right?

And if several years ago, gold was at $500 an ounce and oil was at $50 the ratio would be the same.  So we need to look at the historical ratio and see what a reasonable number of barrels per ounce is.

We used the free market price of gold rather than the government fixed price of $35 / ounce.  We also used the free market price of oil (called stripper) rather than the government fixed price for the period it was fixed.

From that we come up with the following table:

Annual Average # of bbl Oil 1 OZ Gold will buy 
Gold and Crude Price
1946-Present
Year Average $/bbl Average $/oz Ave bbl / oz
1946 $1.63 $38.63 23.696
1947 $2.16 $40.38 18.692
1948 $2.77 $42.38 15.298
1949 $2.77 $41.50 14.982
1950 $2.77 $39.00 14.079
1951 $2.77 $42.00 15.162
1952 $2.77 $39.45 14.242
1953 $2.92 $37.25 12.757
1954 $2.99 $35.38 11.831
1955 $2.93 $35.20 12.014
1956 $2.94 $35.18 11.964
1957 $3.00 $35.20 11.733
1958 $3.01 $35.25 11.711
1959 $3.00 $35.25 11.750
1960 $2.91 $35.85 12.320
1961 $2.85 $35.83 12.570
1962 $2.85 $35.35 12.404
1963 $3.00 $35.34 11.778
1964 $2.88 $35.30 12.257
1965 $3.01 $35.38 11.752
1966 $3.10 $35.40 11.419
1967 $3.12 $35.39 11.341
1968 $3.18 $39.68 12.476
1969 $3.32 $39.35 11.852
1970 $3.39 $37.40 11.032
1971 $3.60 $40.95 11.375
1972 $3.60 $57.30 15.917
1973 $4.75 $95.25 20.053
1974 $9.35 $156.15 16.701
1975 $7.67 $168.80 22.008
1976 $13.10 $130.25 9.943
1977 $14.40 $158.60 11.014
1978 $14.95 $221.55 14.819
1979 $25.10 $406.25 16.185
1980 $37.42 $672.60 17.974
1981 $35.75 $531.30 14.862
1982 $31.83 $420.75 13.219
1983 $29.08 $472.05 16.233
1984 $28.75 $382.20 13.294
1985 $26.92 $332.85 12.364
1986 $14.44 $411.80 28.518
1987 $17.75 $475.55 26.792
1988 $14.87 $472.05 31.745
1989 $18.33 $415.75 22.681
1990 $23.19 $411.35 17.738
1991 $20.20 $400.90 19.847
1992 $19.25 $368.85 19.161
1993 $16.75 $392.50 23.433
1994 $15.66 $411.10 26.252
1995 $16.75 $404.05 24.122
1996 $20.46 $384.55 18.795
1997 $18.64 $323.85 17.374
1998 $11.91 $293.95 24.681
1999 $16.56 $289.15 17.461
2000 $27.39